The Islamic State, or the main reason for the millions of refugees from Syria?

11954641_10153068008880913_177967441271450496_n

The vast majority of television programs, articles and so called experts talking about millions of refugees from Syria have the same discourse: the problem is the Islamic State (IS). Some even say that we should coordinate with the Assad regime and its allies Russia and the Islamic Republic of Iran to resolve and end the problem of the IS and therefore refugees. Without being surprised by these statements, I’m still a little disillusioned.

To be clear, the IS is an ultra reactionary and barbaric organization, killing and terrorizing whole populations of all religions and ethnicities. This ultra reactionary organization forced into exile hundreds of thousands of people, and probably even more than one million, between Iraq and Syria [1]. This movement must be fought relentlessly, like other religious fundamentalist organizations of the region such as Al Qaeda and other jihadist and Salafist forces backed by Gulf monarchies or private networks of these countries, but before reaching the solution against such organizations, I would like to simply remind some facts about the reasons for the exile of millions of people from Syria.

Firstly, the establishment of the IS in Syria was in Autumn 2013 and already before that millions of Syrians were displaced outside and inside the country.

On September 3, 2013, the UNHCR declared that the number of Syrians forced to flee as refugees in foreign countries since the beginning of the popular uprising in Syria in March 2011 had exceeded the threshold of two millions. This meant an average of about 5000 Syrians fleeing on daily basis to neighboring countries. Over 97% of Syrian refugees were hosted in countries located in the surrounding area. In addition, some 4.25 million people were displaced within Syria, according to statistics dating from August 27, 2013 published by the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Taken together, these figures totaled more than six million displaced people.

The reasons that prompted millions of people to flee their homes were the Assad regime that killed, bombarded and repressed large parts of the Syrian population who had risen against its tyranny and barbarism. Here are some examples.

In October 2012, the entire Al Masaa Arbaeen’s neighborhood in the city of Hama, whose inhabitants were seen as favorable to the opposition of the Damascus regime, was destroyed. 3256 buildings in total were completely destroyed.

In May 2013, the historic pedestrian bridge over the Euphrates in the city of Deir Zor was bombed by the Syrian regime. It allowed to access the city of Hasakeh. Its destruction deprived of access tens of thousands of people.

In July 2013, in the city of Homs, called the capital of the revolution at the beginning of the uprising, in which some 900,000 people were living at the beginning of 2011, 60-70% of Khaldiyé district was destroyed, most the houses were uninhabitable, the neighborhoods of Old Homs were in ruin and destruction of the besieged neighborhoods of Homs was done in a systematic way, according to the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights. The city was under siege and bombardment of the regime’s forces since February 2012.

From the end of summer 2012, the regime began to bomb certain neighborhoods of Aleppo.

The Palestinian refugee camp of Yarmouk in Damascus has suffered a hard and strict siege imposed from summer 2013, with the prohibition of movement of persons and foodstuffs, to the neighborhoods that joined the uprising South of Damascus, by the Assad regime and Palestinians organizations linked to the latter, in particular the Popular Front of the Liberation of Palestine – General Command (PFLP-GC), controlled by Ahmad Jibril. There was between 15 000 and 20 000 people in the camp in November 2014, before 2011 Yarmouk had a total population of 250,000 people.

This is not to mention the massive use of rape by the security forces and militias of the regime against the female opponents and civilians and others or the chemical attacks of the regime against some regions such as in the countryside of Damascus region, Ghouta, in August 2013.

But what about after the establishment of the IS in October 2013 in Syria? Was this still the case? Yes absolutely, let’s look at the facts for the first six months of 2015. The helicopters of the Assad regime dropped 10.423 barrels bombs on various regions of the country, while the regime forces killed almost 90% of the total civilians dead over the same period, seven times more than the IS.

In March 2015, human rights defense NGOs investigated the terrible atrocities of the regime: almost 13,000 Syrians have died under torture in its jails since the beginning of the uprising. Tens of thousands more are still languishing in the regime’s prisons, and many are missing.

In May 2015, around hundred people, mostly civilians, were killed in a raid of the Syrian military aviation on a market in the city of Douma.

Barbarism has many faces in Syria and that of the Assad regime is the worst. The Assad regime and its allies (Iran, Russia and Hezbollah) are responsible in its vast majority of the more than 200 000 people killed (and even more than 300 000 according to some sources) in Syria and of the around 10 million of external and internal refugees since the uprising began in March 2011.

Conclusion

So what is the solution? The solution does not lie in the collaboration with authoritarian regimes like the Assad regime. The solution is of course to oppose the IS and other reactionary and jihadists forces, which as a reminder the Assad regime has encouraged their developments at the beginning of the popular uprising in Syria while killing and repressing democratic and progressive forces, but also and especially the barbaric, criminal and authoritarian regime of Assad. The Assad regime is the main responsible of the disaster in Syria and of the exile of millions of Syrians. Both actors are barbaric and they feed themselves and are therefore to be overthrown to hope to build a democratic, secular and social society in Syria and elsewhere.

This requires the support of democratic and popular movements that oppose these two counter revolutionary forces and different forms of imperialism (United States and Russia) and sub-regional imperialisms (Iran, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Turkey) that are all fighting against the interests of the people in struggle in the region. These activists still exist in Syria struggling every day, despite all the difficulties, against the Assad regime and the Islamic fundamentalist forces (2). For example, let’s also consider the case of Iraq, the country in which the IS originated. In recent weeks a popular movement developed and expanded, which challenged the regime in Baghdad, backed by Iran. These massive demonstrations called for a secular state in opposition to a sectarian state, against the division between Sunni and Shi’a populations, for women’s rights and equality, and clear condemnations of sectarian political parties. The demonstrators also accused the sectarian Iraqi regime to be partly responsible by its policies for the development of the IS as we could read on some placards saying “the parliament and the Islamic State are two sides of the same coin” and “Daech was born out of your corruption”.

Beyond the situation in the Middle East and North Africa, we do not forget the negative role of the imperialist Western states in this situation. The racist and security policies of the European Union (EU) on migration are also responsible for the daily dramas of refugees on the roads, land and sea, to Europe. The policies of the border closure pushed hundreds of thousands of people fleeing war and misery to use illegal and dangerous means to try to reach European countries. Just as we need to condemn the imperialist policies of the EU and the war caused by this latter responsible of political and economic problems that are also the sources of displacement of populations and therefore of creating more refugees.

It is with this understanding that we can get out of the nightmare of dictatorships and fundamentalisms of all kinds and especially enable millions of people to have a dignified and free life.

Joseph Daher

[1] See articles on this blog that has always condemned the Islamic State or other religious fundamentalist organizations in the region.

2) See many articles and posts on this blog that show this popular resistance.

11 thoughts on “The Islamic State, or the main reason for the millions of refugees from Syria?

  1. You forget that Ahrar ash-Sham was formed as the first Al-Qa’ida franchise in Syria even before any of the demonstrations. Then when the first demonstrations occurred the first fatalities were Police and Army followed by civilian casualties – quite probably as a result of Islamists and foreign agents attempting to inflame the situation

  2. Actually really hard to know where to start with the glaring inaccuracies in this excuse for an article: I will start with Yarmouk. There are less than 1000 left in Yarmouk currently and the majority of those are sympathetic to the FSA and other terrorist factions occupying Yarmouk. http://dissidentvoice.org/2015/04/who-are-the-starving-and-besieged-residents-of-yarmouk-and-why-are-they-there/
    Please read Sharmine Narwani’s article on the background and true situation in the Palestinian camps within Syria..bearing in mind, she actually visited the camps and garnered information from on the ground not from a Neocon thinktank. https://thewallwillfall.wordpress.com/2014/11/11/stealing-palestine-who-dragged-palestinians-into-syrias-conflict-sharmine-narwani-for-rt/
    You might like to read accounts from the civilian population of Aleppo that again gainsay your appallingly badly researched propaganda:
    https://thewallwillfall.wordpress.com/category/aleppo/
    Guessing you are aiming for a job in politics. Your rhetoric perfectly suits David Cameron and Hammond’s murderous intent and would make you a budding war pundit. SOAS should be ashamed if it gives you a PhD based upon this type of utterly non academic, biased, propagandist and inaccurate story telling. Fail.

  3. “It is with this understanding that we can get out of the nightmare of dictatorships and fundamentalisms of all kinds and especially enable millions of people to have a dignified and free life.”

    Paul Larudee of the Free Palestine Movement

    “There is not a single member of our species who lives free of the tyranny of others. We can only choose our form of tyranny while waging an unending struggle for our our rights and freedoms. Syria is forced to deal with the fact that its ability to be free is constrained by the insistence of the US, Israel, NATO and other entities to meddle in its affairs. Until this changes, Syrians will have to choose between freedom and independence, because they will not be permitted both in equal measure.”

  4. In addition to Vanessa Beeley’s timely remarks, I would like to add a few considerations:

    -You rightly recognize that US Imperialism is “fighting against the interests of the people in struggle in the region”.
    But you also attribute the same blame to Russia. However, Russia’s conduct is in no way comparable to that of the US, which Stratfor’s George Friedman spells out so well:

    In Sum: The US gets to invade other countries, but other countries don’t get to invade us. We control all the oceans and we use the “divide & conquer” strategy to destroy the nations that might become our rivals, while causing millions of deaths.
    This is a most criminal conduct, and it is responsible for most of the destabilization in the Middle East and Ukraine (https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2014/02/07/ukra-f07.html).
    If a Russian individual uttered Friedman’s words, the Western powers would be campaigning to bomb Russia back to the Stone Age.

    -Western powers – not Russia – planned to destabilize Syria since 2009. The US (not Russia) has used terrorists in order to destroy Syria’s secular government:
    medium.com/insurge-intelligence/officials-islamic-state-arose-from-us-support-for-al-qaeda-in-iraq-a37c9a60be4

    -Even if you still believe that Russia is as bad as the US, what makes you think that a group of individuals – with no backing from any major world power – would be able to bring stabilization, order & democracy in the Middle East?
    What you are asking would lead directly to the lawlessness and tragedy we are witnessing in Libya. Maybe you are a highly idealistic person – but idealism without pragmatism can only cause more suffering and destruction.

    -You demonize Assad, but you should remind your readers that before the West decided to destabilize Syria, that was one of the safest countries in the world, and one of the few places in the Middle East that still allowed freedom of religion:
    http://www.realclearworld.com/lists/top_5_personal_safety_countries/syria.html
    No one was trying to escape from Assad’s “regime” before foreign intervention, covert and overt.

    -You should also remind your readers that since the start, many members of the uprising were showing violent and murderous intentions: “The Christians to Beirut, the Alawites to the grave” was one of the main slogans of their campaign.
    http://world.time.com/2012/03/01/eyewitness-from-homs-an-alawite-refugee-warns-of-sectarian-war-in-syria/
    How was that supposed to bring freedom & democracy?

    What we must conclude is that the tragedy we’re witnessing in Syria is the result of foreign meddling – US, UK, France, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and others–but certainly not Russia.

    Assad’s government is by no mean perfect. But you should be aware that the same can be said for Europe (which is NOT a democracy: https://professorwerner.wordpress.com/) and the US (http://www.salon.com/2013/08/17/chomsky_the_u_s_behaves_nothing_like_a_democracy/).

    To assume that violent uprisings and foreign meddling can bring democracy & order is terribly naive and dangerous. The fact that you – and the most powerful members of the Western establishment – do not understand this simple fact is one of the reasons why the world today is in such grave danger.

    • Russia of course has no interests in Syria, does not have any military bases, does not have any military on the ground, and nor has it provided tanks, howitzers, or military aircraft to billions of dollars.

  5. Just another article that simplistically and criminally maligns an entire people and their elected President, leading to mass emigration and unbelievable suffering!
    How much did they pay you to betray your country? No amount of money can ever justify what you have done. I have heard many excuses from terrorist supporting assholes like yourself, none of them can ever come close to being justification for the resultng chaos and betrayal.
    I am a westerner whom has watched helplessly as this hideous drama played out, from the beginning I received videos of Men dressed as Women and carrying guns and machetes, firing on passersby, killing people. A spontaneous revolution? Have you really convinced yourself of this? 50yrs Muslim Brotherhoood gang has been trying to destroy Syria for Israel, your betrayal and your vile deceptions have contributed to this being a viable posibility.
    Shame on you!

  6. There can’t be no doubt that the Syrian ABSP-Regime has by way of its in later years liberal-economic policies, its longstanding disregard for even a formal democracy and its brutal crackdown on any opposition added much to the upheaval four years ago and the current catastrophic situation. There also can’t be no doubt that inside and outside of Syria there have been and are many forces who didn’t need any of these shortcomings to oppose the ABSP-rule – not just US- and European imperialism who could not be happy with a regime granting the Soviet Union and later the Russian Federation a maritime basis in a region full of western imperialist basis, but more importantly the Muslim Brotherhood and assorted islamist forces opposing any regime not based on the traditional sector of the local bourgeoisie and its “religious” ideology, cornered by the economic policies of Assad father and son. That said we ought to face the fact that how much we might favor “democracy” (as for western observers something we would do well to implement as a reality in our own countries instead of a formal fake in the first place) we have to think about the fact that nowhere in the MIddle East anything getting even near to that mentioned deficient democracy has been established up to now. Doesn’t this have something to say about the structure and the level of socio-economic development of the local societies? If so the real alternative is not what any well-meaning individuals of that often cited ominous “civil society” might try to propagate, but various forms of more or less dictatorial regimes or total chaos which by any means the people can bare even less than a bloody central dictatorship: In the case of Syria this is the unpleasant choice between a comparatively “modern” and secular regime (even if for tactical reasons it is prone to instrumentalize communalist feelings) and the reactionary takfiri armed opposition. It’a pipe dream to think that when the air is filled with the sound of the gun an allegedly “moderate” oppositional force like the FSA (now at best controlling but 5% of the rebel territory), let alone an unarmed “civil society” would be heard.

  7. Pingback: Understanding Russian’s military expansion in Syria, or consolidating the Assad regime | Syria Freedom Forever – سوريا الحرية للأبد

  8. Pingback: Les dynamiques de l’expansion militaire russe en Syrie, ou la volonté de sauver et consolider le régime Assad | Syria Freedom Forever – سوريا الحرية للأبد

  9. Pingback: Les dynamiques de l’expansion militaire russe en Syrie, ou la volonté de sauver et consolider le régime Assad - You'll Never Walk Alone

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s